Access WashingtonEFSEC Banner

The Council and it's Jurisdiction
How the Certification Process Works
Facilties Under Review or Certified
Laws Rules & Policies
Rulemaking
Council Meetings
Staff Contacts
Site Map
Links
EFSEC Home

Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Project
Application No. 2013-01
Adjudication

EXHIBIT LIST

Numerical List of Exhibits


Rebuttal Witnesses for the Applicant and Admitted Exhibits for July 28
Transcript

Witness Greg Rhoads

Exhibits Related to Mr. Rhoads Testimony

Witness David Corpron

Exhibits Related to Mr. Corpron's Testimony

Witness Michelle Hollingsted

Exhibits Related to Ms. Hollingsted's Testimony

Witness Brad Roach

Exhibits Related to Mr. Roach's Testimony

Witness Jared Larrabee

Exhibits Related to Mr. Larrabee's Testimony

Rebuttal of Witnesses

Robert Blackburn

Tyler Clary

Robert Chipkevich

Michael Hildebrand

Audie Huber

Robert Johnson

Scott Johnson

Daniel Kegley

Fred Millar

Joseph Molina

Ranajit Sahu

Joseph Wartman

Rebuttal Witnesses for the Applicant and Admitted Exhibits for July 27
Transcript

Witness Chris Barken

 

Rebuttal Witnesses for the Applicant and Admitted Exhibits for July 26

Transcript

Witness Elliot Taylor

Witness Greg Challenger

  • Exhibits Related to Mr. Challenger's Testimony

Witness Jo Reese

Witness J. Kelly Thomas

  • Exhibits Related to Mr. Thomas's Testimony

Witness Marc Bayer

  • Exhibits Related to Mr. Bayer's Testimony

Rebuttal of Witnesses

Kathryn Brigham

Robert Blackburn

Stuart Ellis

James Holmes

Audie Huber

Linda Garcia

Ian Goodman

Ernie Nieme

Blaine Parker

Zachary Penney

Stanley Rice

Ranajit Sahu

Wilbur Slockish Jr.

Admitted on July 25
Transcript

Witness David Wechner

  • PreFiled Testimony of
    David Wechner

    5901-000002-CRK
    Curriculum Vitae of David L. Wechner, M.S. AICP.
    5902-000054-CRK
    David L. Wechner, Comments on the Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Distribution Terminal Draft Environmental Impact Statement (Jan. 14, 2016).
    5903-000156-CRK
    City of Vancouver, Vancouver Comprehensive Plan: 2011–2030 (2011).
    5904-000071-CRK
    City of Vancouver, Fruit Valley Sub Area Plan (Sept. 20, 2010).
    5905-000055-CRK
    City of Vancouver, Riverview Gateway Subarea Plan (Feb. 2, 2009)
    5906-000024-CRK
    City of Vancouver, Vancouver City Center Vision & Subarea Plan (June 18, 2007).
    5907-000229-CRK
    City of Vancouver and Clark County, Regional Trail & Bikeway Systems Plan (2006).
    5908-000020-CRK
    City of Vancouver, Ordinances M-4090 (Sept. 11, 2014), M-4118 (Mar. 2, 2015), and M-4132 (Aug. 17, 2015).
    5909-000014-CRK
    Johnson Economics, Predicted Impacts of the Tesoro Savage Facility on Development and Redevelopment in Downtown Vancouver, Washington (Dec. 18, 2013).
    5910-000004-CRK
    Aerial imagery from Google Earth depicting the Fruit Valley, Esther Short, Columbia Way, Riverview, Old Evergreen Highway, and East Old Evergreen Highway.
    5911-000002-CRK
    Northwest Area Committee & Region 10 Regional Response Team, Environmental Protection Agency, Oiled Wildlife Response (Jan. 2013).
    5912-000003-CRK
    Vancouver Municipal Code, Chapter 20.620 (Columbia River Shoreline Enhancement Plan District).
    5913-000014-CRK
    Johnson Economics, Estimated Economic & Fiscal Impacts of the Tesoro Savage Facility on the Waterfront Vancouver Development and Downtown Vancouver (Dec. 9, 2013).
    5914-000001-CRK
    Elliot Njus, “Port of Vancouver to extend multiuse path that will eventually connect downtown to Vancouver Lake,” Oregonian (Aug. 19, 2013).
    5915-000003-CRK
    Port of Vancouver USA, Notice of Mitigated Determination of Nonsignificance (MDNS), Port of Vancouver Trail Project, CP0280/281 (Mar. 21, 2014).
    5916-000002-CRK
    Washington Bikes, Complete the Lower River Road Trail in Vancouver (Aug. 21, 2013).
    5917-000001-CRK
    Vancouver-Clark Parks & Recreation Department, Vancouver Lake Park and Frenchman’s Bar Park.
    5918-000001-CRK
    City of Vancouver, excerpts from Clark County Bicycle & Pedestrian Trail Use Snapshot: Fall 2010.
    5919-000799-CRK
    Vancouver Municipal Code, § 20.630.080 (City Center Waterfront).
    5920-000226-CRK
    City of Vancouver, Shoreline Master Program (Sept. 24, 2012).
    5921-000002-CRK
    Vancouver Municipal Code, Chapter 20.760 (Shoreline Management Area).
    5922-000005-CRK
    National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, excerpts from Sensitivity of Estuarine and Riverine Environments and Wildlife to Spilled Oil, Columbia River Atlas (June 2004).
    5923-000242-CRK
    Excerpts from U.S. Department of
    Commerce, Summaries of Significant U.S. and International Spills, 1967–1991 (Nov. 1992).
    5924-000002-CRK
    City of Vancouver, Waterfront Development Project.
    5925-000002-CRK
    City of Camas, Resolution 1235 (Mar. 6, 2012).
    5926-000011-CRK
    Clark County, Comprehensive Plan: Chapter 13, Shoreline Master Program (Sept. 12, 2012).
    5927-000150-CRK
    Type IV Planned Development, Subdivision Substantial Development, Conditional Use and Variance Permits, and Critical Areas Permit: Columbia Waterfront LLC Vancouver Waterfront Development, Vol. II (June 2009).
    5928-000491-CRK
    Type IV Planned Development, Subdivision Substantial Development, Conditional Use and Variance Permits, and Critical Areas Permit: Columbia Waterfront LLC Vancouver Waterfront Development, Vol. I (June 2009).
    (Please note, PDF is password protected, cannot bates number)
    0244-000100-TSS
    West Vancouver Freight Access Project Final Environmental Assessment: Appendix L: Socioecomonics & Environmental Justice Discipline Report (July 2009)
    0245-000144-TSS
    West Vancouver Freight Access Project Schedule 2-4 Final Environmental Assessment May 2010
    Rebuttal of
    Brian Carrico

Witness James Holmes

  • PreFiled Testimony of
    James Holmes

    1501-000005-ENV
    Resume of James Holmes, ABT Associates
    1503-000095-ENV
    Potential Fishing Impacts and Natural Resource Damages from Worst-Case Discharges of Oil on the Columbia River Report submitted by ABT Associates and Bear Creek Economics
    1503-000024-ENV
    Potential Fishing Impacts and Natural Resource Damages from Worst-Case Discharges of Oil on the Columbia River Report submitted by ABT Associates and Bear Creek Economics
    1503-000075-ENV
    Potential Fishing Impacts and Natural Resource Damages from Worst-Case Discharges of Oil on the Columbia River Report submitted by ABT Associates and Bear Creek Economics
    1503-000076-ENV
    Potential Fishing Impacts and Natural Resource Damages from Worst-Case Discharges of Oil on the Columbia River Report submitted by ABT Associates and Bear Creek Economics
    1503-000093-ENV
    Potential Fishing Impacts and Natural Resource Damages from Worst-Case Discharges of Oil on the Columbia River Report submitted by ABT Associates and Bear Creek Economics
    Rebuttal of
    Greg Challenger

Witness Eric English

  • PreFiled Testimony of Eric English
    1502-000006-ENV
    Resume of Eric English, Bear Creek Economics
    1503-000095-ENV
    Potential Fishing Impacts and Natural Resource Damages from Worst-Case Discharges of Oil on the Columbia River Report submitted by ABT Associates and Bear Creek Economics
    1503-000047-48-ENV
    Potential Fishing Impacts and Natural Resource Damages from Worst-Case Discharges of Oil on the Columbia River Report submitted by ABT Associates and Bear Creek Economics
    Rebuttal of
    Todd Schatzki

Witnesses Chief Mitchell Hicks and Michael Broncheau

Witness Paul Lumley

Admitted on July 22
Transcript

Witness Wilbur Slockish Jr.

  • No Exhibits
    No PreFiled Testimony

Witness Elizabeth Sanchey

Witness Zachary Penney

Witness Stanley Rice

Admitted on July 21
Transcript

Witness Linda Garcia

  • 1012-000001-POR
    Aerial Mosaic Photograph of Port of Vancouver USA (Sept. 21 , 2015)
    5612-000003-CRK
    EJSCREEN point-center ACS Report, Fruit Valley Neighborhood, Vancouver, Washington, produced using EJSCREEN mapper https://ejscreen.epa.gov/mapper/ June 2016.
    3136-000003-VAN
    Half-Mile and One-Mile Buffer Maps

Witness Kathryn Brigham

Witness Russ Gibbs

Witness Audie Huber

Witness Blaine Parker

Witness Stuart Ellis

Admitted on July 20
Transcript

Witness Jerry Johnson

  • PreFiled Testimony of Jerry Johnson
    4002-000001-CWF
    Resume of Jerald Johnson, Johnson Economics.
    4003-000022-CWF
    J. Johnson, Johnson Economics, Inc., Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Distribution Terminal DEIS Independent Review (Jan. 20, 2016).
    4004-000010-CWF
    D. Furchtgott-Roth, Pipelines are Safest for Transportation of Oil and Gas, MANHATTAN INSTITUTE FOR POLICY RESEARCH, ISSUE BRIEF NO. 23 (June 2013).
    4005-000030-CWF
    D. Clark, Extrernality Effects on Residential Property Values: The Example of Noise Disamenities, Grouth and Change (Sept. 2006)
    4006-000025-CWF
    T. Carroll, et al., The Economic Impact of a Transient Hazard on property Values: The 1988 PEPCON Explosion in Henderson, Nevada, 13 Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 2 (1996).
    4007-000014-CWF
    S. Farber, Undesirable Facilities and Property Values: A Summary of Empirical Studies, 24 ECOLOGICAL ECONOMICS (1998).
    4008-000008-CWF
    R. Diaz, Impacts of Rail Transit on Property Values, American Public Transportation Association, Proceedings of 1999 Commuter Rail/Rapid Transit Conference, Toronto, Canada (1999).
    4009-000017-CWF
    D. Forkenbrock, Comparison of External Costs of Rail and Truck Freight Transportation, Transportation Research Part A 35 (2001).
    4010-000111-CWF
    ECONorthwest, Portland Harbor: Industrial Land Supply Analysis, Prepared for the City of Portland: Bureau of Planning and Sustainability (May 2012)
    4011-000018-CWF
    K. Gawande, et al., The Long-Run Impact of Nuclear Waste Shipments on the Property Market: Evidence from a Quasi-Experiment, JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL ECONOMICS AND MANAGEMENT 65 (2013).
    4012-000030-CWF
    M. Fucht, Examining the Spatial Distribution of Externalities: Freight Rail Traffic and Home Values in Los Angeles (Nov. 11, 2011).
    4013-000033-CWF
    M.A.J. Theebe, Planes, Trains, and Automobiles; The Impact of Traffic Noise on House Prices, SBV Research (2002).
    4014-000027-CWF
    G. Debrezion, et al., The Impact of Rail Transport on Real Estate Prices: An Empirical Analysis of the Dutch Housing Market, Tinbergen Institute Discussion Paper, No. 06-031/3 (2006).
    4015-000027-CWF
    K. Gawande and H. Jenkins-Smith, Nuclear Waste Transport and Residential Property Values: Estimating the Effects of Perceived Risks, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management 42 (2001).
    4016-000013-CWF
    R. Simons & A. El Jaouhari, The Effect of Freight Railroad Tracks and Train Activity on Residential Property Values, The Appraisal Journal (Summer 2004).
    4017-000033-CWF
    Washington Physicians for Social Responsibility, Position Statement on Crude Oil Transportation and Storage to Governors of Washington and Oregon from Concerned Washington & Oregon Health Care Professionals (Feb. 2015).
    4018-000083-CWF
    Washington Department of Ecology, Final Cost-Benefit and Least Burdensome Alternative Analysis: Chapter 173-182 WAC, Oil Spill Contingency Plan, Pub. No. 12-08-014 (Dec. 2012).
    0156-000018-TSS
    Primary Impacts Report, July 28, 2014
    0158-000017-TSS
    Statistical Analysis of Potential Property Value Impacts from Vancouver Energy May 13, 2016
    5909-000016-CRK
    Johnson Economics, Predicted Impacts of the Tesoro Savage Facility on Development and Redevelopment in Downtown Vancouver, Washington (Dec. 18, 2013).
    5913-000016-CRK
    Johnson Economics, Estimated Economic & Fiscal Impacts of the Tesoro Savage Facility on the Waterfront Vancouver Development and Downtown Vancouver (Dec. 9, 2013).
    5588-000031-CRK
    Technical Appendix.
    0156-000018-TSS
    Primary Impacts Report, July 28, 2014

Witness Ernie Niemi

Witness Jared Smith

Witness Ranajit Sahu

  • PreFiled Testimony of Ranajit Sahu
    5520-000010-CRK
    Comments of Dr. Ranajit Sahu on Draft Environmental Impact Statement of Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Distribution Terminal
    5521-000004-CRK
    API Staff Analysis of Crude Oil Samples Submitted to PHMSA May 19, 2014.
    5522-000010-CRK
    ConocoPhillips, Safety Data Sheet for Bakken Crude Oil Sweet.
    5523-000038-CRK
    A Survey of Bakken Crude Oil Characteristics Assembled for the U.S. Department of Transportation, submitted by the American Fuel & Petrochemical Manufacturers, May 2014.
    5524-000030-CRK
    Presentation by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) relating to the Differential Absorption Lidar (DIAL) Project, Summer 2007, Texas City, Texas, April 2010.
    5525-000084-CRK
    Millenium Bulk Terminals Draft EIS, GHG Technical Report.
    5526-000019-CRK
    Ranajit Sahu, Ph.D. C.V.
    5527-000002-CRK
    Email from Dan Gunerston to Steven Manlow, August 6, 2015 (Van Ness Bates No. VE-INF-002998)
    5528-000058-CRK
    Vancouver Energy Air Quality Technical Report, August 2014

Admitted on July 19
Transcript

Witness Scott Johnson

Witness Ian Goodman

Rebuttal of

Witness Robert Johnson

Admitted on July 18
Transcript

Witness Brett Vandenhuevel

Cross Examination Exhibits

  • 0001-000470-PCE
    Application May 2016
    1012-000001-POR
    Aerial Mosaic Photograph of Port of Vancouver USA (Sept. 21 , 2015)

Witness Michael Lester

Rebuttal

Witness Joseph Wartman

Rebuttal

Witness Elinor Fanning

  • PreFiled Testimony of Elinor Fanning
    5530-000006-CRK
    Comments of Dr. Elinor Fanning on Draft Environmental Impact Statement of Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Distribution Terminal.
    5531-000007-CRK
    Shi L et al 2016. Environmental Health Perspectives 124:46
    5532-000286-CRK
    Washington State Department of Ecology 2008. Washington Toxic Air Pollutant Priorities Study
    5533-000015-CRK
    Thurston GD et al. 2016 Environmental Health Perspectives 124:484. http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/ehp.1509676. Reviewed in: Hoek et al. 2013 Environmental health 12:43.
    5534-000011-CRK
    Gauderman et al N. Engl J. Med 2004; 351:1057 - The Effect of Air Pollution on Lung Development
    from 10 to 18 Years of Age
    5535-000009-CRK
    Gauderman et al N. Engl J. Med 372:10:095 - Association of Improved Air Quality with Lung Development in Children
    5536-000003-CRK
    EPA Environmental Justice Screen Report - Fruit Valley
    5537-000049-CRK
    Brook RD et al. 2010 Circulation 121:2331 - Particulate Matter Air Pollution and Cardiovascular Disease
    5538-000001-CRK
    Susan Harvey, Review of Draft Environmental Impact Statement for the Tesoro Savage Petroleum Terminal LLC (Jan. 18, 2016)

Admitted on July 14
Transcript

Witness Tyler Clary

Witness Joseph Molina

  • Erratum PreFiled Testimony of Joseph Molina
    PreFiled Testimony of Joseph Molina
    0368-000003-TSS
    Email Correspondence from Steve Eldred to Eric Haugstad - March 24, 2016
    3016-000002-VAN
    Resume of Fire Chief J. Molina filed by the City of Vancouver
    3017-000005-VAN
    Exhibit A to Prefiled Testimony of Fire Chief J. Molina (November 2, 2012, Convus Energy, Material Safety Date Sheet)
    3018-000001-VAN
    Exhibit B to Prefiled Testimony of Fire Chief J. Molina (VFD Service Area Map)
    3020-000003-VAN
    Corrected Exhibit C to Prefiled Testimony of Fire Chief J. Molina (Critical Facilities Map & Key)
    3021-000029-VAN
    Exhibit D to Prefiled Testimony of Fire Chief J. Molina (Railroad Crossings Map)
    3053-000008-VAN
    Requests for Proposals – Risk Assessment, Gap Analysis, and Fire Protection Engineering Assessment related to the proposed Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Distribution Terminal Project
    3079-000003-VAN
    December 13, 2013, City of Vancouver Fire Department Scoping Comments
    3084-000002-VAN
    June 8, 2016, Letter Washington State Council of Fire Fighters to Gov. Inslee
    3124-000071-VAN-Redacted
    Fire Protection Assessment Report for the Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Distribution Terminal

Cross Examination

Rebuttal of Greg Rhoads

  • PreFiled Testimony of Greg Rhoads
    0353-000004-TSS
    CV of Greg Rhoads (Rhoads Att A)
    0200-000002-TSS
    Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) Highway-Rail Grade Crossing Accident/Incident Report April29, 2010
    0261-000012-TSS
    PHMSA Lessons Learned Roundtable Report (July 1, 2014)
    0262-000002-TSS
    Unit Trains Resource Fact Sheet - May 28 2015
    0263-000023-TSS
    Association of American Railroads CPC-1312 (January 27, 2015)
    0264-000007-TSS
    Security and Emergency Response Training Center Example of mrgency Response Training Available to Local Response Groups
    0223-000019-TSS
    Transport Canada Report Runaway & Main-Track Derailment July 6, 2013
    0246-000007-TSS
    Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) Emergency Order No. 28, Notice No.1 August 7, 2012
    0247-000019-TSS
    USDOT Amended & Restated Emergency Restriction/ Probation Order Docket No. DOT-OST-2014-0025 March 6, 2013
    0248-000017-TSS
    USDOT Amended & Restated Emergency Restriction/ Probation Order Docket No. DOT-OST-2014-0067 May 7, 2013
    0196-000392-TSS
    U.S. Department of Transportation Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration, Emergency Response Guidebook (2012)

Cross Examination of Exhibits of Greg Rhoads

  • 3060-000004-VAN
    May 7, 2014, Safety Advisory 2014-01, U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Railroad Administration, Recommendation for Tank Cars
    3087-000028-VAN
    December 4, 2014, U.S. Rail Transportation of Crude Oil: Background and Issues for Congress, Congressional Research Service
    3085-000061-VAN
    2013, Emerging Risks Task Force Report, Region 10 Regional Response Team/Northwest Area Committee
    3039-000000-VAN
    June 3, 2016, Mosier Oregon train derailment spills oil (petroleum), sparks fire – Video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pmRUlzJpZHU
    3067-000395-VAN
    May 1, 2015, Final Regulatory Impact Analysis, Docket No. PHMSA-2012-0082, USDOT, PHMSA
    3008-000005-VAN
    Exhibit to Prefiled Testimony of M. Hildebrand (Examples of DOT-111& CPC-1232 Tank Car Damage & Types of Failures Experienced in Actual Derailments)
    3122-000012-VAN
    Attachment 3 to Prefiled Testimony of R. Blackburn Photographs, Rail Accidents)
    3124-000071-VAN-Redacted
    Fire Protection Assessment Report for the Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Distribution Terminal

Witness Brian Schaeffer

Witness Eric Holmes

  • PreFiled Testimony of Eric Holmes
    3009-000002-VAN
    Resume City Manager E. Holmes Filed by the City of Vancouver
    3044-000022-VAN
    September 30, 2014, Letter E. Holmes to Foxx re Docket No PHMSA2012-0082
    3045-000002-VAN
    September 30, 2014, Letter J. Inslee to Foxx re rules to address safety
    3051-000006-VAN
    May 22, 2014, City of Vancouver’s Request to Defer Land Use Consistency Determination and Leave Record Open
    3052-000008-VAN
    December 13, 2013, Letter City of Vancouver Scoping Comments
    3057-000057-VAN
    May 28, 2014, City of Vancouver’s Comments Regarding Consistency of Proposal with Land Use Plans and Zoning Regulations
    3071-000009-VAN
    April 2016, Millennium Bulk Terminals - Appendix F, Rail and Vessel Corridor Information
    3075-000073-VAN
    April 2016, Millennium Bulk Terminals, EIS, Chapter 6
    3092-000024-VAN
    June 18, 2007, Vancouver City Center Vision & Subarea Plan
    3093-000027-VAN
    January 2008, Central Park Plan
    3094-000038-VAN
    August 25, 2009, Creating a more Sustainable Vancouver Plan
    3095-000100-VAN
    Downtown Vancouver Growth and Transportation Efficiency Center Plan
    3096-000055-VAN
    February 2, 2009, Riverview Gateway Subarea Plan
    3097-000156-VAN
    2011-2030, Vancouver Comprehensive Plan
    3098-000226-VAN
    November 21, 2011, City of Vancouver, Shoreline Master Program
    3099-000015-VAN
    Waterfront Photos
    3100-000008-VAN
    June 3, 2014, City of Vancouver Resolution M-3821
    3101-000008-VAN
    September 11, 2014, ORD M-4090 Moratorium on Crude Petroleum Facilities
    3102-000002-VAN
    March 2, 2015, ORD M-4118 Crude Oil Moratorium Extension
    3103-000006-VAN
    August 17, 2015, ORD M-4132 Continuance of Moratorium on Crude Petroleum Product Facilities.
    3104-000006-VAN
    February 1, 2016, ORD M-4157 Continuance of Moratorium on Crude Petroleum Product Facilities
    3117-000011-VAN
    Old Evergreen Highway Neighborhood, Neighborhood Action Plan, June, 2011
    3131-000001-VAN
    Length of Tesoro Unit Train at Old and New Switch Point Between BNSF Main and Port Rail Tracks
    0253-000333-TSS
    Vancouver City Center Vision Subarea Plan FSEIS
    0254-000083-TSS
    Columbia Waterfront Development Agreement
    0255-000003-TSS
    Staff Report No. 144-09 (10-19-09)
    1022-000129-POR
    Port of Vancouver USA Waterfront Project Master Plan (Nov. 13, 2015)

Rebuttal of Brian Carrico

  • 0222-000073-TSS
    FEIS for Clark County Jail (Vol. I) 1997
    0222-000050-TSS
    FEIS for Clark County Jail (Vol. I) 1997
    0222-000099-TSS
    FEIS for Clark County Jail (Vol. I) 1997
    5902-000056-CRK
    David L. Wechner, Comments on the Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Distribution Terminal Draft Environmental Impact Statement (Jan. 14, 2016).
    0228-000002-TSS
    Fishing Access Sites
    0245-000029-TSS
    West Vancouver Freight Access Project Schedule 2-4 Final Environmental Assessment May 2010
    5912-000005-CRK

    Vancouver Municipal Code, Chapter 20.620 (Columbia River Shoreline Enhancement Plan District).

Witness Matthew Grady

  • 4019-000001-CWF
    Rendering of Completed Columbia Waterfront Development (Downriver View).
    4020-000001-CWF
    Rendering of Completed Columbia Waterfront Development (Upriver View).
    4021-000001-CWF
    Rendering of Completed Columbia Waterfront Development on Aerial Photograph.
    4022-000001-CWF
    Rendering of Completed Columbia Waterfront Development (Aerial View).
    4023-000001-CWF
    Rendering of Completed Vancouver Waterfront Park and Pier.
    4024-000001-CWF
    Rendering of Columbia Waterfront Development Land Use Master Plan.
    4025-000001-CWF
    Land Use Plan for Phase I of ColumbiaWaterfront Development.
    4026-000002-CWF
    Washington Department of Ecology, City of Vancouver Shoreline Conditional Use Permit and Variance Approval (Mar. 31,2010) (issued to Columbia Waterfront).
    4027-000002-CWF
    Washington Department of Ecology, City of Vancouver Substantial Development Permit Approval (Mar. 27 2010).
    4028-000002-CWF
    City of Vancouver, Ordinance M-3936 (Dec. 7,2009).

Admitted on July 13
Transcript

Witness Michael Hildebrand

  • Prefiled Testimony of Michael Hildebrand
    3008-000005-VAN
    Exhibit to Prefiled Testimony of M. Hildebrand (Examples of DOT-111& CPC-1232 Tank Car Damage & Types of Failures Experienced in Actual Derailments)
    3123-000001-VAN
    Problem vs. Response Timeline
    2501-000040-SPO
    Evaluation of Threat Posed by Bakken Crude Oil Tank Trains and Hazardous Materials Transported Through the City of Spokane Washington (PowerPoint Presentation by Michael Hildebrand)

Witness Robert Blackburn

  • PreFiled Testimony of Robert Blackburn
    3058-000206-VAN
    July 2014, Draft Regulatory Impact Analysis, [Docket No. PHMSA-2012-0082] (HM-251)
    3120-000004-VAN
    Attachment 1 to Prefiled Testimony of R. Blackburn (July 22, 2008, BNSF PowerPoint Excerpt)
    3121-000003-VAN
    Attachment 2 to Prefiled Testimony of R. Blackburn (December 2009, US Dept. of Transportation, The Transportation of Hazardous Materials Excerpt)
    3122-000011-VAN
    Attachment 3 to Prefiled Testimony of R. Blackburn Photographs, Rail Accidents)
    3046-000002-VAN
    December 9, 2015, City of Vancouver discovery request to Tesoro and Port of Vancouver
    3047-000005-VAN
    January 8, 2016, Vancouver Energy response to City of Vancouver’s discovery request dated December 9, 2015
    3048-000003-VAN
    May 2, 2016, City of Vancouver’s Second Discovery Requests
    3049-000002-VAN
    June 2, 2016, Vancouver Energy’s response to City of Vancouver’s discovery requests dated May 2, 2016

    REBUTTAL OF:
    Michelle Hollingstad
    1503-000095-ENV
    Potential Fishing Impacts and Natural Resource Damages from Worst-Case Discharges of Oil on the Columbia River Report submitted by ABT Associates and Bear Creek Economics
    0278-000003-TSS
    Summary of Decomissioning Costs June 1, 2016
    3068-000075-VAN
    3068-000010-VAN

    July 23, 2013, Ground Lease Between Port of Vancouver, USA and Tesoro Savage Petroleum Terminal, LLC

Admitted on July 12
Transcript

Witness Susan Harvey

Witness Ryan Lopossa

Witness Robert Chipkevich

  • PreFiled Testimony of Robert Chipkevich
    3125-000005-VAN
    June 23, 2016, Federal Railroad Administration, Preliminary Factual Findings Report, Derailment, Mosier, OR
    3129-000003-VAN
    Derailment Pictures from Heimdal, ND
    3126-000006-VAN
    Feb 17, 2016, National Transportation Safety Board, Locomotive Event Recorder Factual Report, Heimdal, ND
    3127-000026-VAN
    April 14, 2016, National Transporation Safety Board, Hazardous Material Group Factual Report, Heimdal, ND
    3128-000014-VAN
    May 6, 2015,National Transporation Safety Board, Office of Railroad, Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Investigations, Derailment Heimdal, ND
    3059-000002-VAN
    Preliminary Report Railroad, DCA14MR004 – Casselton, ND
    3133-000026-VANNational Transportation Safety Board, Factual Report, Derailment, Office of Railroad, Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Investigations,September 19, 2015
    3134-000009-VAN
    National Transportation Safety Board, Burlington Northern Santa Fe, Derailment Lesterville, SD Septemer 19, 2015
    3028-000013-VAN
    April 30, 2014, National Transportation Safety Board Railroad Accident Brief for Lynchburg
    3029-000018-VAN
    July 8, 2015, National Transportation Safety Board, Tank Car Performance Factual Report for Mount Carbon (Please note, PDF is password protected, cannot bates number)
    3030-000056-VAN
    October 20, 2006, NTSB Accident Report, Derailment of Norfolk Southern Railway Company Train 68QB119 with Release of Hazardous Materials and Fire, New Brighton, PA
    3003-000004-VAN
    Attachment 1 to Prefiled Testimony of R. Chipkevich (Photographs, October 6 &7, 2015, Track Conditions within City of Vancouver)
    3032-000191-VAN
    July 6, 2013, Railway Investigation Report R13D0054, Runaway and Main-Track Derailment – Montreal, Maine & Atlantic Railway Freight Train MMA-002, Lac-Mégantic, Quebec (Please note, PDF is password protected, cannot bates number)
    3060-000004-VAN
    May 7, 2014, Safety Advisory 2014-01, U.S. Department of Transportation, Federal Railroad Administration, Recommendation for Tank Cars
    3110-000013-VAN
    August 11, 2015, Washington Utility & Transportation Commission Inspection Report

Witness Jim Appleton

Admitted on July 11
Transcript

Witness Keith Casey

  • No Exhibits

Witness Greg Rhoads

Witness Brian Dunn

Admitted on July 7
Transcript

Witness Michelle Hollingstad

  • PreFiled Testimony of Robert Blackburn
    1503-000095-ENV
    Potential Fishing Impacts and Natural Resource Damages from Worst-Case Discharges of Oil on the Columbia River Report submitted by ABT Associates and Bear Creek Economics
    0278-000003-TSS
    Summary of Decomissioning Costs June 1, 2016
    3068-000075-VAN
    July 23, 2013, Ground Lease Between Port of Vancouver, USA and Tesoro Savage Petroleum Terminal, LLC
    3068-000010-VAN
    July 23, 2013, Ground Lease Between Port of Vancouver, USA and Tesoro Savage Petroleum Terminal, LLC

Witness Greg Challenger

  • PreFiled Testimony of Greg Challenger
    0296-000001-TSS
    CV - of Greg Challenger (Challenger Att. A)
    0108-000002-TSS
    March Recovery Studies
    0229-000022-TSS
    Challenger, G., Sergy, G., and Graham, A., 2008. Vegetation Response and Sediment Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon Attenuation in a Carex marsh in Howe Sound, British Columbia, Canada Following a Spill of Bunker C Fuel Oil. International Oil Spill Conference Proceedings
    0230-000077-TSS
    Bauersfeld, K. 1977. Effects of peaking (stranding) of Columbia River dams on juvenile anadromous fishes below The Dalles Dam, 1974 and 1975. State ofWashington Department ofFisheries, Technical Report No. 31. Report to the U.S. Anny Corps of Engineers, Contract DACW 57-74-C-0094
    0201-000008-TSS
    Results from a sixteen year study on the effects of oiling from the Exxon Valdez on adult pink salmon returns. Marine Pollution Bulletin 52, 892-899Brannon, E. A Maki, L Moulton, K Parker, 2006 Online publication date: August 1, 2005
    0207-000042-TSS
    Review of the Exxon Valdez Oil Spill Effects on Pink Salmon in Prince William Sound Alaska. Reviews in Fisheries Science E. L. Brannon, et al. Online publication date: January 11, 2012
    0243-000047-TSS
    U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Biological Opinion on proposed the Continued Operations and Maintenance Dredging Program for the Columbia River Federal Navigation Channel in Oregon and Washington (2014-2018)
    0269-000206-TSS
    Fate and Effects of the Mobileoil Spill in the Columbia River (NOAA)
    0277-000126-TSS
    NOAA/API Oil Spills in Marshes Planning & Response Considerations (September 2013)
    0287-000013-TSS
    Marine Pollution Bulletin "Prolonged recovery of sea otters from the Exxon Valdez oil spill? A re-examination of the evidence"
    0288-000025-TSS
    Human and Ecological Risk Assessment "Kille Whale (Iricinus orca) Deaths in Prince William Sound Alaska, 1985 - 1990
    PreFiled Testimony of James Holmes
    PreFiled Testimony of Eric English
    PreFiled Testimony of Dr. Stanley Rice
    PreFiled Testimony of Roger Dick, Jr.
    Prefiled Testimony of Stuart Ellis

Witness Elliott Taylor

  • PreFiled Testimony of Elliott Taylor
    PreFiled Testimony of Susan Harvey
    0001-000317-PCE
    Application May 2016
    0001-002561-PCE
    Application May 2016
    0001-002993-PCE
    Application May 2016
    0001-002712-PCE
    Application May 2016
    0001-003213-PCE
    Application May 2016
    0324-000001-TSS
    CV of Elliot Taylor (Taylor Att A)
    0147-000001-TSS
    Summary of Inspections
    0148-000001-TSS
    EPA & USCG Defined Petroleum-Based Pil Groups
    0149-000001-TSS
    Ranges of Physical Properties for Example Oil Type
    0150-000001-TSS
    Tank & Flume Experimental Results for Changesin Wathered Oil Density
    0151-000002-TSS
    ADIOS Modeling Results for Bakken and Dilbit Scenarios
    0152-000001-TSS
    Summary of Fate & Behavior and Potential Adverse Effects on Emvironment for Major Oil Types
    0153-000001-TSS
    WDOE Map of PRC Equipment
    0154-000001-TSS
    EX-0051-PCE (DEIS, Appendix D.4, Section 7.1.8 Excerpts)
    0201-000008-TSS
    Results from a sixteen year study on the effects of oiling from the Exxon Valdez on adult pink salmon returns. Marine Pollution Bulletin 52, 892-899Brannon, E. A Maki, L Moulton, K Parker, 2006 Online publication date: August 1, 2005
    0224-000010-TSS
    BNSF Railway, Northwest Division, Fallbridge Subdivision, Reference to NW ACP Geographical Response Plan April 8, 2013
    0225-000019-TSS
    BNSF Railway, Northwest Division, Lakeside Subdivision, Reference to NW ACP Geographical Response Plan April 8, 2013
    0226-000052-TSS
    BNSF Railway, Northwest Division, Scenic Subdivision, Reference to NW ACP Geographical Response Plan April 8, 2013
    0227-000133-TSS
    Powerpoint Slides, BNSF Railway, Fallbridge Subdivision Oil Spill Control Points (CCPs) April 2013
    0229-000022-TSS
    Challenger, G., Sergy, G., and Graham, A., 2008. Vegetation Response and Sediment Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon Attenuation in a Carex marsh in Howe Sound, British Columbia, Canada Following a Spill of Bunker C Fuel Oil. International Oil Spill Conference Proceedings
    0235-000087-TSS
    Environment Canada, 2013. Properties, Composition, and Marine Spill Behaviour, Fate and Transport of Two Diluted Bitumen Products from the Canadian Oil Sands (30 November 2013; rev. April 2014)
    0236-000028-TSS
    SL Ross, 2012. Meso-scale Weathering of Cold Lake Bitumen/Condensate Blend. Report prepared for Enbridge Northern Gateway. Filed with the National Energy Board, February 6, 2013
    0258-000037-TSS
    American Petroleum Institute, Sunken Oil Detection and Recovery Operational Guide (December 2015)
    0259-000119-TSS
    American Petroleum Institute, Sunken Oil Detection and Recovery Technical Report (December 2015)
    0275-000162-TSS

    CRREL and SLRoss, 2015. Investigation of the Behavior of Diluted Bitumen and Heavy Conventional Crude Oil Spills. Report to the American Petroleum Institute
    0276-000021-TSS
    Taylor, E., Challenger, G., Rios, J., Morris, J. McCarthy, M.W., and C. Brown. 2014. Dilbit Crude Oil Weathering on Brackish Water: Meso-scale Tests of Behavior and Spill Countermeasures
    0277-000162-TSS
    NOAA / API Oil Spills in Marshes Planning & Response Considerations (September 2013)
    0369-000016-TSS
    Maritime Fire & Safety Association Comment Letter January 22, 2016
    0206-000278-TSS
    MFSA Vessel Response Plan, Umbrella Oil Spill Contingency Plan for Covered Vessels, Columbia and Willamette Rivers (Rev. 02) (July 14, 2013)
    0292-000187-TSS
    MFSA Vessel Response Plan
    Revision 09 - 03/18/2016
    5501-000054-CRK
    Applicants Responses to EFSEC and agency review comments (Jan. 2014).
    5502-000242-CRK
    Vancouver Energy Terminal Quantitative Vessel Traffic Risk Assessment, Report No. PP111860-2, Rev. 5, January 20, 2016.
    5503-000015-CRK
    Attachment ES-1 to the Applicants January 22, 2016 Comments on DEIS.
    5504-000326-CRK
    Vancouver Energy Comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement, Submitted to EFSEC,
    5505-000007-CRK
    U.S. Energy Information Administration, Alaska State Profile and Energy Estimates, October 15, 2015.
    5506-000009-CRK
    U.S. Energy Information Administration, Hawaii State Profile and Energy Estimates, October 15, 2015.
    5507-000001-CRK
    Lower Columbia Region Harbor Safety Committee, Columbia River Incident Management Guidelines.
    5508-000008-CRK
    Baker Engineering and Risk Consultants, Inc., Review of Tesoro-Savage DEIS, Final Report, January 22, 2016, prepared for the Applicant.
    5509-000451-CRK
    Vancouver Energy, Spill Response Exercise Report, January 12, 2016.
    5510-000026-CRK
    Polaris Applied Sciences, Inc., A Comparison of the Properties of Diluted Bitumen Crudes with Other Oils, 2013.
    5511-000241-CRK
    FOSC Desk Report for the Enbridge Line 6b Oil Spill Marshall, Michigan, April 2016.
    5512-000113-CRK
    Lower Columbia Region Harbor Safety Plan, Columbia River Incident Management Guidelines 03.10.10, 2012.
    5513-000187-CRK
    MFSA Vessel Response Plan, Columbia and Willamette Rivers, Overall Plan Revision 09, March 18, 2016.
    5514-000001-CRK
    Preliminary Pre-Booming Diagram, Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Distribution Terminal, Application NO. 2013-01 Supplement, February 2014, Page 2-154.
    5516-000038-CRK
    Susan Harvey, Review of Draft Environmental Impact Statement for the Tesoro Savage Petroleum Terminal LLC (Jan. 18, 2016)
    5517-000001-CRK
    Susan Harvey C.V.

Admitted on July 6
Transcript

Witness Dava Kaitala

  • PreFiled Testimony of Dava Kaitala
    0110-000155-TSS
    BNSF’s Comments in Response to Publication of Draft Environmental Impact Statement, TSDT
    0111-000006-TSS
    BNSF Grade Crossing Safety Brochure
    0112-000003-TSS
    WA DOT Response to WA State Dept. Fish & Wildlife comments on the Pacific NW Rail Corridor Program Env’l Assessment
    0113-000027-TSS
    BNSF Rail Safety Presentation
    0224-000101-TSS
    BNSF Railway, Northwest Division, Fallbridge Subdivision, Reference to NWACP Geographical Response Plan
    April 8, 2013
    0225-000019-TSS
    BNSF Railway, Northwest Division, Lakeside Subdivision, Reference to NWACP Geographical Response Plan
    April 8, 2013
    0226-000052-TSS
    BNSF Railway, Northwest Division, Scenic Subdivision, Reference to NWACP Geographical Response Plan
    April 8, 2013
    0227-000113-TSS
    Powerpoint Slides, BNSF Railway, Fallbridge Subdivision Oil Spill Control Points (CCPs)
    0237-000046-TSS
    Pacific Northwest Marine Cargo Forecast Update & Rail Capacity Assessment - Final Report
    December 2011
    PreFiled Testimony of Wayne Senter
    PreFiled Testimony of Robert Johnson

Witness John Hack

Witness Ken Ames

Witness Larry Guthrie

  • PreFiled Testimony of Larry Guthrie
    1006-000006-POR
    Résumé of Larry R. Guthrie, to Guthrie Testimony TUV Rheinland Mobility (Attachment to Guthrie Testimony)
    1007-000001-POR
    Résumé of Cory J. Hogan, TUV Rheinland Rail Sciences, Inc. (Attachment to Guthrie Testimony)
    1008-000039-POR
    Train Operations Study, Port of Vancouver Conne.ction Track, Final Report, Prepared for HDR Engineering, Inc. by TUV Rheinland Mobility Rail Sciences Division (Feb. 19,2014)(Attachment to Guthrie Testimony)
    1009-000019-POR
    Port of Vancouvsr, T-5 Loop Track Assessment, Final Report, Prepared for Port of Vancouver by TUV Rheinland Mobility, Inc. Rail Sciences Division (May 11, 2016) (Attachment to Guthrie Testimony)
    1010-000036-POR
    Port of Vancouvsr, T-5 Loop Track Assessment, Final Report, Prepared for Port of Vancouver by TUV Rheinland Mobility, Inc. Rail Sciences Division (May 11, 2016) (Attachment to Guthrie Testimony)
    1012-000001-POR
    Aerial Mosaic Photograph of Port of Vancouver USA (Sept. 21 , 2015)
    PreFiled Testimony of Michael Hildebrand

Admitted on July 5
Transcript

Witness J. Kelly Thomas

Witness David Sawicki

Witness Dennis O'Mara

  • PreFiled Testimony of Dennis O'Mara
    Curriculum Vitae of Dennis O'Mara
    0120-000242-TSS
               -000116-TSS
               -000106-TSS
               -000008-TSS
               -000010-TSS
               -000134-TSS
               -000131-TSS
    Quantitative Vessel Traffic Risk Assessment, January 2016
    0121-000118-TSS
    Vessel Traffic Risk Impact Analysis & Vessel Traffic Risk Assessment September 2014

Witness Eric Haugstad

Admitted on June 30
Transcript

Witness Matthew Shanahan

Witness Mark Rohrback

Witness Todd Schatzki

Admitted on June 29
Transcript

Witness Eric Hansen

Witness Marc Bayer

Witness Daniel Shafar

  • 0358-000028-TSS
    Pre-filed Testimony of Daniel Shafar
    0359-000004-TSS
    CV of Daniel Shafar (Shafar Att A)
    0209-000005-TSS
    BergerABAM Letter to EFSEC, Response to 19 February, 2016 Letter Re Industrial NPDES Permit Application
    3004-000011-VAN
    Prefiled Testimony of T. Clary filed by the City of Vancouver
    3005-000001-VAN
    Exhibit A to Prefiled Testimony of T. Clary (August 20, 2013, Letter Clary to Adams re water availability)
    3006-000005-VAN
    Exhibit B to Prefiled Testimony of T. Clary (Water Engineering Comments)
    0284-000003-TSS
    E-Mail from D. Davis to D. Shafar 2013 0520 re Port of Vancouver - Fire Flow & Water System Maps
    0285-000002-TSS
    E-Mail from D. Davis to D Shafar 2013 0524 re Hydrant Flow Tests
    0286-000001-TSS
    E-mail for G. Hancock to D Shafer 2013 0530 Re Fire Flow Tests
    0220-000001-TSS
    Hydrant Test Location Map
    0221-000018-TSS
    Keyera LP Gas Facility- StaffReport and Decision, April 16, 2010
    0219-000004-TSS
    Hydrant Test- Facility Areas 200 & 600
    0209-000058-TSS
    BergerABAM Letter to EFSEC, Response to 19 February, 2016 Letter Re Industrial NPDES Permit Application Review May27, 2016
    0194-000276-TSS
    The Fire Protection Research Foundation, One Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA- Fire Pump Field Data Collection and Analysis, Final Report (April 2012).

Admitted on June 28
Transcript

Witness Brian Carrico

  • 0222-000073-TSS
    FEIS for Clark County Jail (Vol. I) 1997
    0222-000050-TSS
    FEIS for Clark County Jail (Vol. I) 1997
    0222-000099-TSS
    FEIS for Clark County Jail (Vol. I) 1997
    5902-000056-CRK
    Type IV Planned Development, Subdivision Substantial Development, Conditional Use and Variance Permits, and Critical Areas Permit: Columbia Waterfront LLC Vancouver Waterfront Development, Vol. II (June 2009).
    0216-000004-TSS
    Washougal Pump Station Photos
    0228-000002-TSS
    Fishing Access Sites
    0245-000029-TSS
    West Vancouver Freight Access Project Schedule 2-4 Final Environmental Assessment May 2010
    5912-000005-CRK
    Vancouver Municipal Code, Chapter 20.620 (Columbia River Shoreline

Witness David Corpron

Admitted on June 27
Transcript

Witness - Brad Roach

  • 0322-000003-TSS
    Curriculum Vitae of Brad Roach
    0321-000021-TSS
    Pre-Filled Testimony of Brad Roach
    0129-000001-TSS
    Map by the U.S. Energy Information Administration that depicts the PADDs
    0130-000001-TSS
    Map by the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers Showing Pipeline Infrastructure
    0143-000001-TSS
    California and Alaska Crude Oil Production, MBPD
    0144-000001-TSS
    ANS Production/ WC Refining System
    0145-000001-TSS
    Map Showing Gloval Crude Ouk Reserves
    0131-000001-TSS
    Lawrence Livermore Nation Laboratory (LLNL) Estimated California Energy Use in 2012; Est Alaska Energy Use, Arixona Energy Use, Est Hawaii Energy Use, Est Nevada Energy EST Oregon Energy, Est Washington Energy, Est U.S,. Energy Use in 2012; LLNL Estimated U.S. Energy Use in
    2013; LLNL U.S. Energy Use in 2014; LLNL U.S. Energy
    Use in 2015
    0136-000001-TSS
    PADD 5 Growth Outlook, MBPD/Historical Demand
    0272-000001-TSS
    Figure: Foreign Crude Price, $/BBL and Petroluem Consumption, MBBLS/Day
    0271-000001-TSS
    Figure: U.S. Crude Oil Stock Levels, MBBLS

Witness - Alastair Smith

  • 1011-000001-POR
    Résumé of Alastair Smith, Chief Marketing/Sales Officer, Port of Vancouver USA
    1012-000001-POR
    Aerial Mosaic Photograph of Port of Vancouver USA (Sept. 21 , 2015)
    1013-000001-POR
    Port of Vancouver USA Facilities Map and Tenant List (May 2016)
    1015-000001-POR
    Photograph of Old Viaduct Looking East on 6th Street in Vancouver with White Truck in Background
    1017-000001-POR
    NOAA Columbia River Navigation Charts (Chart Nos. 18521, 18523, 18524. & 18252)
    1018-000001-POR
    Overview Chart of Recent Years' Revenue for Port of Vancouver USA (Rating Presentation by Port of Vancouver USA to Standard and Poor's May 17, 2016)
    1019-000001-POR
    2014 Economic Impacts of Port of Vancouver USA Seaport and Non-Maritime Real Estate Tenants - Summary of Results (2014 Economic Impact of the Port of Vancouver USA: Executive Summary, Martin Associates Nov. 10, 2015)
    1020-000001-POR
    Funding Sources for V/est Vancouver Freight Access Project (Port of Vancouver USA website. May 23, 2016
    1021-000001-POR
    Port of Vancouver USA Strategic Plan 2016-2025 (Revised Dec 2015)
    1022-000001-POR
    Port of Vancouver USA Waterfront Project Master Plan (Nov. 13, 2015)

Witness - Jared Larrabee

Back to:

Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Project main page


For information or questions concerning this application please contact:     

Sonia Bumpus, EFSEC Siting Specialist/Project Manager 
Energy Facility Site Evaluation Council 
PO Box 43172 
Olympia, WA 98504-3172
(360) 664-1363

Top of page

 

Home Page | About EFSEC | Certification | Energy Facilities 
Laws & Rules
|
Rulemaking | Meetings | Staff Contacts  
Site Map | Links | Privacy Notice   

Access Washington Logo  

www.efsec.wa.gov
Question or Comment? Contact EFSEC at efsec@utc.wa.gov

Top of the Page

Back to:
Tesoro Savage Vancouver Energy Project main page

 

DAILY PROPOSED LIST OF WITNESSES SCHEDULED TO APPEAR


    July 29, 2016
    Transcript AM
    Transcript PM

    Closing Arguments

    Members of the Public will be Heard from
    1:00PM to 5:00PM

     

    Ground Rules

    Comments MUST be restricted to facts and evidence presented by the attorneys during the adjudication.  No Exceptions

     

    No Written Comments will be Received

     

    Pre-Arranged Group Spokespersons will Speak First for 3 Minutes Each

     

    Followed by Speakers who will be Selected by Lottery and Allotted 2 Minutes Each to Speak

    July 28, 2016
    Transcript

    Continued from
    July 27
    Greg Rhoads
    Rail and Facility Incident Issues

    David Corpron
    Facility Design and Permitting

    Michelle Hollingstad
    Financial Assurances

    Brad Roach
    Facility

    Jared Larrabee
    Facility Management

    July 27, 2016
    Rebuttal Witnesses
    Transcript

    Chris Barken
    Rail Issues Expert

    Greg Rhoads
    Rail and Facility Incident Issues

    David Corpron
    Facility Design and Permitting

    July 26, 2016
    Rebuttal Witnesses
    Transcript

    Elliot Taylor
    Spill Response

    Greg Challenger
    Impacts Spill Reponse

    J. Kelly Thomas
    Facility Risks
    Insurance Matters

    Captain Marc Bayer
    Vessel Practices
    Air Issues

    Brad Roach
    Oil Market
    Economic Impacts Related to Washington State

    Jo Reese
    Cultural Resources via Telephone

    July 25, 2016
    Transcript

    Mr. David Wechner

    Land Use

     

    Mr. English
    Impacts to Commercial and Recreational Fishing as a Result of a Worst Case Discharge Scenario

     

    Mr. Holmes
    Natural Resource Damage Assessments and in Particular the Abt Report's Worst Case Discharge Scenarios

     

    Joint - Mr. Mitch Hicks/Mr. Michael Broncheau
    Fisheries Enforcement, Fishing Access Sites, Rail Safety
    Tribal First Response

     

    Mr. Paul Lumley
    Tribal Cultural Values and Significance of the Fisheries to Tribes

    July 22, 2016
    Transcript

    Mr. Wilbur Slockish
    Tribal Fisher
    Spill Impacts 

    Ms. Elizabeth Sanchey
    Mosier Tribal Response 

    Mr. Randy Settler
    Tribal Fisher
    Moiser Incident

    Mr. Roger Dick
    Tribal Fisher
    Rail

    Mr. Zachary Penney
    Potential Effects of Increased Crude Oil Transport on the Columbia River Anadromous Salmonids

    July 21, 2016
    Transcript

    Linda Garcia
    Fruit Valley Neighborhood

     

    Mr. Stuart Ellis
    Zone 6 Tribal Fishing Methods

     

    Ms. Kathryn Brigham
    Umatilla Indian Reservation

     

    Mr. Audie Huber
    Umatilla Indian Reservation

      

    Mr. Blaine Parker
    Potential Effects to Aquatic Species

    July 20, 2016
    Transcript

    Jerry Johnson
    Socioeconomic Impacts

    Ernie Neime
    Secondary Economic Impacts

    Jared Smith
    Fact Witness

    Susan Harvey
    Via Phone to Answer Council Questions

    Ranajit Sahu
    Air Issues

    July 19, 2016
    Transcript

    Scott Johnson
    Emergancy Management Issues

    Ian Goodman
    Oil Economics

    Timothy Walsh
    Department of Natural Resources
    Need to Assess Landslide Issues in the Columbia Gorge

    Robert Johnson
    Department of Natural Resources
    Wildfire Issues

    July 18, 2016
    Transcript

    Brett Vandenhuevel  Columbia Riverkeeper- Moiser Accident

    Dr. Joseph Wartman  Seismic, Earthquake, Liquefaction, Rebuttal of Rohrback, Shanahan, Corpron

    Michael Lester
    City of Vancouver Assistant Police Chief, Emergency Services and evacuation Rebuttal Sawicki

    Elinor Fanning
    Air Toxic/Public Health Rebuttal Hansen

    July 14, 2016

    Tyler Clary
    Water Supply

    Joseph Molina
    Fire and Emergency Management and Response

    Eric Homes
    Land Use and Public Policy

    Matt Grady
    Fact Witness to the Description of the Columbia Waterfront Development

    Brian Schaeffer
    Impacts to the City of Spokane's Fire and Emergency Response Capacbility from Increase in Oil Train Density

    July 13, 2016

    Michael Hildebrand
    Emergency Response

    Robert Blackburn
    Financial Assurance

    July 12, 2016
    Transcript

    Susan Harvey
    Oil Spill Risk and Response Planning

    Ryan Lopossa
    Rail Crossing Delays

    Jim Appleton
    Moiser Fire Chief

    July 11, 2016
    TRANSCRIPT

    Keith Casey
    Financial Assurances/Joint Venture

    Greg Rhoads
    Rail Incident Response

    Brian Dunn
    Rail Crossing

    July 7, 2016
    TRANSCRIPT

    Brian Dunn
    Rail Traffic
    Did Not Appear

    Michelle Hollingstad
    Financial Assurances

    Elliot Taylor
    Spill Preparedness and Response

    Greg Challenger
    Spill Related Biology

    July 6, 2016
    TRANSCRIPT

    Dava Kaitala
    BNSF Rail Operations

    John Hack
    Rail Operations

    Larry Guthrie
    Rail Operations

    Brian Dunn
    Rail Traffic
    Did Not Appear

    July 5, 2016
    TRANSCRIPT

    J. Kelly Thomas
    Facility Risk Issues

    David Sawicki
    Emergency Repsonse Plan and Site Safety

    Dennis O'Mara
    Transfer Load

    Eric Haugstad
    Spill Prevention

    June 30, 2016
    TRANSCRIPT

    Todd Schatzki
    Economics

    Mark Rohrbach
    Seismic

    Matthew Shananhan
    Seismic

    Eric Haugstad
    Spill Prevention
    Did Not Appear

    June 29, 2016
    TRANSCRIPT

    Randy McDougal Jr.
    Via Teleconference

    David Corpron
    Continued from June 28

    Eric Hansen

    Marc Bayer

    Daniel Shafar

    John Hack
    Did Not Appear

    June 28, 2016
    TRANSCRIPT

    Jared Larrabee
    Continued from June 27

    Brian Carrico

    David Corpron

    Daniel Shafar
    Did Not Appear

    Marc Bayer
    Did Not Appear

    JUNE 27, 2016
    TRANSCRIPT

    Brad Roach

    Alastair Smith

    Jared Larrabee

    Witnesses Who Have Provided PreFiled Testimony but Were Not Called as Witnesses

    The Applicant - Tesoro Savage Petroleum Terminal, LLC.

    Dan Gunderson
    Daniel Roscoe
    Kristin Wallace
    Glenn Grette
    Nicolas Nash
    Lars Olavson
    Russ Gibbs
    Jeff Hale
    Norm Bennion
    Vladmir Shepsis
    Ken Ames

    The Port of Vancouver

    Chris Earle

    City of Spokane

    Daniel Kegley

    City of Vancouver

    Wayne Senter

    City of Washougal

    Dan Monaghon
    Carl Einberger

    Clark County

    Eric Peterson

    Columbia Riverkeepers

    Fred Millar
    Frank James

    Confederated Tribes fo the Umatilla Indian Reservation, Confederated Tribes and Bands of the Yakama Nation and Columbia River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission

    Robert Brigham